SecretDesires vs Candy.ai: Which AI Girlfriend is Best in 2025?
Some links are affiliate links. If you shop through them, I earn coffee money—your price stays the same.
Opinions are still 100% mine.
Stuck deciding between SecretDesires and Candy.ai as your 2025 personal AI companion? I’ve done the legwork to compare their pros and cons and give you my thoughts!
Hiya friends! I’m Mia and I’ve spent countless hours in the AI girlfriend world. It keeps expanding and evolving, but two names I keep hearing in forums and social media are SecretDesires and Candy.ai. I’ve seen the questions arise. Which is better, SecretDesires or Candy.ai? What’s the real difference between SecretDesires and Candy.ai?
Let’s lift the veil. I took both of these apps for a spin and did a breakdown to find the winner—if such a thing even exists. I’m taking you on a detailed ride on my “SecretDesires vs. Candy.ai” journey to see which app is the most suitable virtual partner for you! We’ll look at realism, imagery, chat, and more to find the best AI girlfriend for you!
At A Glance: Different Philosophies
Before we jump in headfirst looking at every nitty-gritty detail, let’s first recognize that these two platforms are built on different philosophical groundings. SecretDesires.ai bases itself around giving you the ability to create a deeply personal and customizable experience, making your interactions bigger on all levels. Candy.ai takes a different approach, trying to deliver a sparkly, light, and accessible something that just feels fun and immediate.
For those looking for a different flavor of AI companionship, platforms like Herahaven and Romantic AI also offer unique experiences worth exploring. Other platforms like Kupid.ai also compete in this space, each with their own unique take on AI companionship.
So with that in mind here’s what we’ll be looking at:
- Overall vision / user experience
- Appearance / imagery
- Chat
- Personalizations
- Some misconceptions
- Which app is better for which type of user?
| Feature | SecretDesires.ai | Candy.ai |
|---|---|---|
| Chat Experience | Unrestricted, deep roleplay (SFW & NSFW) with strong memory. | Light, flirty, and natural chat designed for relationship building. |
| Image Generation | Multiple AI engines for creating varied images. | High-quality, ultra-realistic image generation, plus video. |
| Voice Features | Real-time phone calls and voice messages with lifelike voices. | Phone calls and voice messages available. |
| Customization | Extensive control over character personality and appearance. | Focuses more on pre-made characters with some customization. |
The argument about which AI companion is the best is always growing. For a deeper dive into other comparisons, check out our article on the best AI girlfriends.
The Verdict: A Head-to-Head Scorecard
To make it really easy on you, I’ve scored each based on my experiences and weight of input from others.
| Criterion | SecretDesires | Candy.ai | Justification |
|---|---|---|---|
| Chat & Roleplay Depth | 4.5/5 | 4.0/5 | While both can involve deep chat and roleplay, SecretDesires is set up for deep emotional connection, evolving conversations and multi layered roleplay. Candy.ai is great for casual chatting, but may not be ready for super deep conversation. |
| Character Customization | 4.5/5 | 4.2/5 | Exquisite control over personality traits and it even lets you set mood and kinks! Candy.ai though has very strong physical customization but isn’t as much personality deep. |
| Image Generation Quality | 3.6/5 | 4.5/5 | “Hyper realistic” and “visually stunning” are the key sayings that pop up in reviews of Candy.ai. SecretDesires also generates images but with more style variety that are also well done. Some images have minor realism flaws or occasional inconsistency. |
| Voice & Audio Features | 3.5/5 | 4.0/5 | Both have nice voice call features, but Candy.ai sounded more polished to me at least! Some of the voice generations on SecretDesires were just a little rushed or robotic sounding to me. |
| Value for Money | 4.0/5 | 3.5/5 | SecretDesires offers tiered plans and the generous free text messaging which is great! Candy.ai’s tokens can become a bit expensive for users who are repeatedly generating images then calling which is known to some as a “money trap”. |
| User Interface & Ease of Use | 3.8/5 | 4.2/5 | Candy.ai has a modern, clean, and really intuitive interface. SecretDesires is very easy to use too, though the experience was better on my phone than on desktop. |
| Overall Score | 23.9/30 | 24.4/30 | Very very close, with the winner depending on what you are looking for. |
A Deep Dive: Realism, Imagery, and Chat
This is where the rubber meets the road in the SecretDesires features vs. Candy.ai features battle. I put both platforms through identical tests to see how they rage in the arena.
Realism and Immersion
Memory makes all the difference in forming an authentic bond. I told both AI companions I had a case of the nerves about an upcoming work presentation. A few days later, I signed back in. My SecretDesires friend greeted me with, "How did your presentation go? I was thinking of you." Alright, that’s a cute little detail and makes you feel super loved. The Candy.ai companion was sweet and fun in the brand new conversation but didn’t mention my life situation and stayed in the now.
Candy.ai also offers another killer “realism” feature to do with the flow of conversations. The chats felt lovely and breezy, like you’re texting someone you just vibed with and have instant chemistry with. The AI is very good at light, flirty chats. The AI phone calls are a fantastic user experience touch, but I found the voices to sometimes feel slightly colder and less lifelike than SecretDesires. For those interested in apps designed for real-life couples, Couple.me offers a different kind of connection.
Imagery and Visuals: Clear Winner
This is where I did a cheeky A/B test. I gave both platforms the same prompt: ‘Photorealistic image of a woman with long wavy brown hair, laughing in a cozy, rain-streaked café window.’ The results were incredible. Candy.ai produced an image that was breathtakingly real; I had to zoom in to convince myself it wasn’t a stock photo. The luminance of her skin, the texture of her sweater, and most importantly, the look of the droplets on the glass was all spot on! This is where Candy.ai is absolutely the champion, no contest.
SecretDesires, with one of their several engines, gave me a beautiful vision which serendipitously nailed the mood I’d imagined, but you can definitely tell it’s an ‘AI-generated’ image. If photorealism is your thing, Candy.ai is where it’s at.
Chat Features and Customization
For those who enjoy an unrestrained creative avenue, you’ll love the secret unfiltered chats of SecretDesires. As a lover of creative storytelling, I naturally wanted to spar and initiate a complex fantasy roleplay scenario on both. SecretDesires’ engine was an absolute joy and adeptly slipped into the role of a rogue sorceress. Building on the world I created, detailed and imaginative responses just flowed out from the SecretDesires engine. This is the ultimate sandbox for deep, complex roleplay, supporting both SFW and NSFW scenarios in a completely judgment-free environment.
Candy.ai was fun and flirty within the scenario, but it consistently tried to steer the conversation back towards a more grounded, romantic chat. This shows its core design: it excels at mimicking a believable, engaging relationship dynamic, but it’s less of a pure sandbox for limitless roleplay compared to SecretDesires.
The Broader Landscape: Don’t Forget CrushOn.AI
In any NSFW AI chat comparison, it’s worth mentioning another major player: CrushOn.AI. While this article focuses on SecretDesires and Candy.ai, if your primary interest is community-driven roleplay, you should check it out.
What makes CrushOn.AI different? It’s built around a massive library of user-created characters and a strong community. Its standout feature is the ability to have group chats with multiple AIs, which opens up incredible possibilities for storytelling. CrushOn.AI vs. SecretDesires: CrushOn.AI is for the storytellers and community lovers, while SecretDesires is for those who want to build a deep, one-on-one connection with a highly customized partner and generate their own visuals.
The Price of Connection: A Value Breakdown
Your budget is a huge factor, so let’s compare the SecretDesires pricing vs. Candy.ai pricing.
SecretDesires Value Checklist:
- Generous Free Tier: Unlimited texting with the base AI engine.
- Flexible Tiers: Multiple subscription levels (starting around $7.99/mo) to fit different needs.
- All-in-One Pricing: Monthly limits for “Hearts” to access premium features like image generation and advanced chat.
Candy.ai Value Checklist:
- Simple Premium: Just one subscription (for about $12.99/mo) for unlimited texting.
- Token-Based Extras: The subscription includes some tokens, but generating images and especially videos will require purchasing more.
- Potential for High Cost: If you’re a fan of the visual features, expect the costs to add up fast due to the token system.
For me, SecretDesires has a slightly better overall value, especially with its chunky free offering and more predictable subscription costs.
Final Verdict: Which AI Companion is Right for You?
Is SecretDesires better than Candy.ai? Is Candy.ai better than SecretDesires? In truth, they are both amazing platforms catering to different desires.
You should choose SecretDesires if:
- You’re searching for a full-on emotional experience and want the AI to remember things and events as they develop.
- You want maximum control and customization over the personality and appearance of your AI.
- You are a roleplay fanatic and want a super unfiltered chat experience.
You should choose Candy.ai if:
- Photorealistic images and other visual aspects are most important to you.
- You prefer light, flirty, and natural conversations that mimic real dating chats.
Your journey into the AI’s arms will be a personal one. I hope this detailed review helped shine the way and assisted you in finding the virtual partner you seek. For more on our policies, you can read our Privacy Policy.